Guide ID Score in each domain(%) Score in each domain(%) Score in each domain(%) Score in each domain(%) Score in each domain(%) Score in each domain(%) number of fields (n) number of fields (n) number of fields (n) Overall evaluation Consistency Test Consistency Test Consistency Test
1 2 3 4 5 6 ≥60% 30%~60% ≤30% ICC 95%CI P
Werfel et al., 2016 75.00 55.55 47.62 91.66 33.33 50.00 2 4 0 B 0.943 0.867,0.976 <0.001*
Galli et al., 2016 91.66 58.33 28.57 86.11 31.25 91.66 3 2 1 B 0.96 0.909,0.983 <0.001*
Wong et al., 2017 94.44 80.55 23.81 86.11 27.08 100.00 4 2 0 B 0.97 0.93,0.987 <0.001*
Boguniewicz et al., 2017 80.55 91.66 59.52 86.11 27.08 87.50 3 2 1 B 0.963 0.914,0.984 <0.001*
Wollenberg et al., 2018 88.88 91.66 91.66 97.22 77.08 100.00 6 0 0 A 0.886 0.751,0.95 <0.001*
Katoh et al., 2019 91.66 91.66 80.95 77.77 68.75 91.66 6 0 0 A 0.911 0.801,0.961 <0.001*
Chow et al., 2018 58.33 38.88 71.42 80.55 60.41 70.83 4 2 0 B 0.859 0.697,0.938 <0.001*
Kent. & Clark., 2018 83.33 50.00 17.85 77.77 31.25 58.33 3 2 1 B 0.945 0.874,0.976 <0.001*
MaHTAS, 2018 100 91.66 80.95 88.88 87.5 62.5 6 0 0 A 0.785 0.550,0.905 <0.001*
Aoki et al., 2019 41.66 27.77 20.23 58.33 22.91 83.33 1 2 3 C 0.829 0.639,0.924 <0.001*
Damiani et al., 2019 36.11 25.00 23.81 41.66 14.58 50.00 0 3 3 C 0.917 0.815,0.964 <0.001*
Chiricozzi et al., 2019 47.22 8.33 27.38 83.33 10.41 100.00 0 3 3 C 0.935 0.850,0.972 <0.001*
Rajagopalan et al., 2019 66.66 55.55 55.95 69.44 25.00 66.66 3 2 1 B 0.891 0.762,0.952 <0.001*
Katoh et al., 2020 58.33 52.77 57.14 69.44 27.08 100.00 2 3 1 B 0.887 0.752,0.950 <0.001*
Chan et al., 2021 50.00 27.77 21.42 77.77 35.41 100.00 2 2 2 B 0.902 0.783,0.957 <0.001*
Atopic Dermatitis Working Group., 2020 36.11 19.44 5.95 47.22 4.16 25.00 0 2 4 C 0.949 0.885,0.978 <0.001*
Lee et al., 2021 58.33 11.11 50 94.44 22.91 37.5 1 3 2 B 0.894 0.762,0.955 <0.001*
WFCMS., 2020 5.55 5.55 3.57 8.33 2.08 0 0 0 6 C 0.497 0.105,0.705 0.008*
Kulthanan et al., 2021 66.66 38.88 36.9 80.55 4.16 58.33 2 3 1 B 0.889 0.753,0.953 <0.001*
Average 64.76 48.53 42.35 73.83 32.23 70.17 - - - - - - -