First author Year Study design Follow-up (Months) ICE Sample size ICE Sample size Gender (male%) Gender (male%) Age Age Hypertension (%) Hypertension (%) Paroxysmal AF Paroxysmal AF LAAO device LAAO device
ICE Group TEE Group ICE Group TEE Group ICE Group TEE Group ICE Group TEE Group ICE Group TEE Group ICE Group TEE Group
Gianni 2021 Single-center 2 122 68 66 60 72±8 75±9 NA NA NA NA Watchman FLX Watchman FLX
Pommier 2021 Single-center 1 175 49 70 73 76±8 75±7 91 96 29 23 Watchman/ACP Watchman/ACP
Alkhouli 2020 Single-center 1.5 90 196 62.2 55.6 75.7 ± 8.0 75.2 ± 7.8 92.2 87.2 NA NA Watchman Watchman
Hemam 2019 Multi-center 4 53 51 62.3 60.8 77±10 76±7 81 90 NA NA Watchman Watchman
Nielsen-Kudsk 2019 Multi-center 12 130 955 60 65 75 ± 8 75 ± 9 NA NA NA NA Amulet Amulet
Berti 2018 Multi-center 15 187 417 66 65 76 ± 8 74 ± 7 NA NA 32 36 ACP/Amulet ACP/Amulet
Kim 2018 Multi-center 25.6 41 103 58.5 49.5 71.4±9.3 72.3±9.2 90.2 83.5 34.1 27.2 Watchman/ACP/Amulet Watchman/ACP/Amulet
Frangieh 2017 Single-center 0 32 44 81 57 74.6±9.3 80.3±7.7 84 86 69 54 Watchman Watchman
Korsholm1 2017 Single-center 1.7 109 107 62 74 73.0 ± 7.8 73.0 ± 9.7 83 80 48 42 ACP/Amulet ACP/Amulet
Reis 2018 Single-center 23 26 56 53 53 74±8 74±8 86.6 86.6 30.5- 30.5- Watchman/ACP/Amulet Watchman/ACP/Amulet
Dallan 2022 Single-center 1.5 136 55.1 76 ± 8.4 85.3 53.7 Watchman FLX Watchman FLX
Turagam1 2022 Single-center 12 15 33 71.3 ± 10.8 Watchman Watchman
Chen 2022 Single-center 12 56 57.1 69.4 ± 7.5 69.6 41.1 LAmbre LAmbre
Turagam2 2021 Single-center 1.5 30 53 75.4 ± 8.4 90 NA Watchman Watchman
Filby 2021 Single-center 1.5 71 54.9 76±8.8 81.7 59.2 Watchman/Watchman FLX Watchman/Watchman FLX
Korsholm2 2020 Single-center 1.7 92 25 73.3 ± 8.5 76 51 Watchman FLX Watchman FLX
Khalili 2019 Single-center 0 15 73 75.6 ± 10 NA 13.3 Watchman Watchman
Matsuo 2016 Single-center 1.5 27 40.7 77.0±8.5 88.9 14.8 Watchman Watchman
Masson 2015 Single-center 2 37 67.6 74.7±8.2 94.6 51.3 ACP ACP
Berti 2014 Multi-center 0 121 57 77±7.6 89.3 20.7 ACP/Amulet ACP/Amulet